Free Shipping on $45+ with code FREESHIP45 | Details

Filters

Category
  • Amish Fiction
  • Animal Books & Magazines
  • Best Selling Fiction Books
  • Blackberry Valley Mysteries
  • Book Sets
  • Christian Fiction Books
  • Christian Fiction Romance
  • Cozy Mysteries
  • eBooks
  • Fiction eBooks
  • General Fiction Books
  • Gift Shop Mysteries
  • Holiday Fiction
  • Mysteries & Wonders of the Bible
  • Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm
  • Mysteries of Lancaster County
  • Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard
  • Mysteries of Silver Peak
  • Mystery Christian Fiction
  • New Release Christian Books
  • Patchwork Mysteries
  • Sale
  • Savannah Secrets
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic
  • Secrets of Mary's Bookshop
  • Secrets of the Blue Hill Library
  • Secrets of Wayfarers Inn
  • Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries
  • Tearoom Mysteries
  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries
Price

Mystery Christian Fiction

Category
  • Amish Fiction
  • Animal Books & Magazines
  • Best Selling Fiction Books
  • Blackberry Valley Mysteries
  • Book Sets
  • Christian Fiction Books
  • Christian Fiction Romance
  • Cozy Mysteries
  • eBooks
  • Fiction eBooks
  • General Fiction Books
  • Gift Shop Mysteries
  • Holiday Fiction
  • Mysteries & Wonders of the Bible
  • Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm
  • Mysteries of Lancaster County
  • Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard
  • Mysteries of Silver Peak
  • Mystery Christian Fiction
  • New Release Christian Books
  • Patchwork Mysteries
  • Sale
  • Savannah Secrets
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic
  • Secrets of Mary's Bookshop
  • Secrets of the Blue Hill Library
  • Secrets of Wayfarers Inn
  • Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries
  • Tearoom Mysteries
  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries
Price
  • When There's a Will Book Cover

    Following the death of Seth’s Uncle Silas, the Miller family is spending time mourning the loss of a loved one. Meanwhile, Levi is relieved to hear that he will inherit land from Silas, but will the arrival of a shady developer—coinciding with the disappearance of the deed to Silas’s land—threaten Levi’s ownership of the property? As always, Cheryl and her friends from Sugarcreek are on the case!

  • Do You See What I See Book Cover

    January arrives in Lancaster, and the whole town is fascinated by a serialized mystery story running in the local newspaper. Things take a strange turn when Jan becomes convinced that she’s found a cryptic code embedded in the text of the mystery, and things get even stranger when Elaine begins to suspect that the story’s villain is modeled after her! Can the intrepid cousins discover who is behind the not-socomplimentary story—and what the coded clues reveal? Meanwhile, Jan, increasingly consumed with the details of her upcoming wedding to Bob, is faced with the difficult task of securing a location for her wedding tea, until help arrives from a surprising source.

  • Mysteries of Lancaster County Book 8: Seek & Ye Shall Find-0

    Author: DeAnna Julie Dodson

  • Garage Sale Secrets - Mysteries of Lancaster County - Book 2

    Author: Elizabeth Ludwig

  • Mysteries of Lancaster County Book 11: Pride and Pettiness-0

    Author: Elizabeth Ludwig

  • To a Tea Book Cover

    When a well-traveled individual with an interesting past applies for a job at Jan and Elaine’s tearoom, the cousins can only think that nothing is as it seems. On top of this, just as the tearoom prepares to host its first wedding, the groom mysteriously disappears! Could this be related to a recent bank robbery in town? As Jan and Elaine investigate the mysterious series of events, one can only wonder… will these cases ever be solved, or are they chasing dead ends? Find out in To a Tea, another cozy offering from Lancaster, Maine!

  • No Time for Trouble Book Cover

    Cheryl is delighted to be a part of Sugarcreek’s annual Ohio Swiss Festival, but when repeated acts of vandalism threaten to harm the festival’s reputation, she is determined to get to the bottom of everything. However, when Cheryl discovers that her neighbors may have information that could help her solve this mystery, she must hurry to warn them that they may be the next victims of foul play! Find out how this mystery unwinds in yet another adventurous offering from the picturesque town of Sugarcreek!

  • Savannah Secrets - Facing the Facts - Book 23-0

    Author: Beth Adams

  • Horse Sense and Sensibility - Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Book 22

    As horses from all over Sugarcreek are reported missing, Cheryl and Levi must investigate the matter before other individuals lose their beloved animals! Meanwhile, Cheryl discovers a diary about an Englischer who fell in love with an Amish man, but never acted on her feelings due to her fear of their societal differences. Can Cheryl learn to reveal her growing affection for Levi, or is she destined to the same fate as the woman in the diary?

  • Savannah Secrets - Honeybees & Legacies - Book 17-0

    Author: Shaen Layle

  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic Book 22: A Marathon of Kindness-0

    Amy’s daughters discover an old coin in their great-grandfather’s jar, leading to a surprising revelation about his past. Meanwhile, Amy and her husband receive a mysterious wedding gift, sparking curiosity about the anonymous sender’s identity.

  • Family Patterns - Patchwork Mysteries Series

    Sarah Hart, a widowed mother of two, has recently moved back to Maple Hill with her son Jason and his family. While restoring Jason’s new home, they discover a hidden passage containing an ancient quilt! As Sarah embarks on an investigation to uncover the secrets of the quilt, she realizes that it holds more secrets than she ever could have imagined.

  • Time to Share Book Cover

    After Sarah and Martha discover a secret cellar built into Mount Greylock, an investigation is in order! In the cellar, Sarah finds many items from recent burglaries in the area, as well as an old daguerreotype depicting a young couple. Who are they, and what role do they play in this puzzling mystery?

  • Muslin Mystery Book Cover

    While restoring a quilt for a client, Sarah discovers that the blocks of the quilt spell out a cry for help! With her client refusing to relinquish any information regarding the quilt, as well as various locals warning her about possible danger, Sarah must solve this mystery quickly before she puts herself in harm’s way!

Popular products

Community Newsletter

Get More Inspiration Delivered to Your Inbox

Donate to change a life together

Scroll to Top