The local theater in Sugarcreek is hosting a live production of Simply Sugarcreek, but someone is attempting to sabotage the event! After a crew member disappears, Cheryl realizes that she has to quickly uncover the saboteur, or else it may be lights out for the show! Will the show go on, or is this a mystery that is too puzzling for even Cheryl?
Levi Miller leaves Cheryl in charge of his land while he’s out of town, but it soon becomes clear that someone is tearing up Levi’s fields! Who would want to hurt Levi’s business ventures? Alongside her new friend, Zoey Marsalla, Cheryl must get to the bottom of this mystery before the Millers risk losing their crops for the season!
As horses from all over Sugarcreek are reported missing, Cheryl and Levi must investigate the matter before other individuals lose their beloved animals! Meanwhile, Cheryl discovers a diary about an Englischer who fell in love with an Amish man, but never acted on her feelings due to her fear of their societal differences. Can Cheryl learn to reveal her growing affection for Levi, or is she destined to the same fate as the woman in the diary?