Filters
Mystery Christian Fiction
-
Life has never been fuller for Cheryl Miller. Since baby Rebecca joined the family, it seems there are fewer hours in a day and more things to do than ever before. But when Cheryl’s youngest sister-in-law, Esther, is caught with drugs, Cheryl knows she must make the time to help. Esther insists the drugs aren’t hers, but refuses to provide further information. Esther’s friend Henry thinks Englisher Zachary Waller is to blame.
Could Henry simply be wrestling with a bad case of jealousy, since he has always had strong feelings for Esther, and Esther’s attraction to Zachary is plain to see? With strange incidents mounting, Cheryl races to get to the bottom of the sudden influx of drugs in their small community before Esther finds herself in real trouble. But can she do it in time?
Secrets Plain and Simple – Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries – Book 27
Starting at $17.95 $7.99 -
When Anne learns of a new tax proposal that may be introduced, she is thrilled to hear that the new policy can open up more opportunities for her library. However, when children’s books are stolen from Anne’s library, it becomes apparent that someone doesn’t want the tax proposal to pass in the town council. Can Anne and her friends discover who is behind the mischief? Meanwhile, Ben starts spending more time with his new friend, Joey. But is there more to Joey than first meets the eye? Find out in Off the Shelf, another heartwarming tale from Blue Hill!
Off the Shelf – Secrets of the Blue Hill Library – Book 6
Starting at $9.99 -
Anton Birken has returned to Sugarcreek to attend his mother’s funeral. He was shunned a decade ago after the suspicious disappearance of a teenage Amish girl he liked. While the girl’s parents, and the community, suspected Anton of foul play, the police lacked evidence to arrest him. When Levi allows Anton to stay in their dawdy haus, Cheryl is more than a little worried— especially when another teen girl vanishes after Anton’s arrival. Has the girl simply run away, or has something more sinister transpired?
Meanwhile, Cheryl entertains Sharon Vogel, a gifted quilter from Lancaster County whose quilts Cheryl wants to sell at the Swiss Miss. However, when local stores experience a wave of peculiar thefts—including one of Sharon’s valuable quilts—Cheryl finds herself embroiled in two mysteries instead of one. Or are they somehow related?Quilt by Association – Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries – Book 28
Starting at $17.95 $7.99 -
“Make an effort.” These three seemingly innocuous words send Cheryl Miller on her most challenging assignment yet. When Aunt Mitzi handpicks a new tenant for her cottage, she asks Cheryl to “make an effort” to befriend her. But Jayla Nuttall makes it plain she doesn’t welcome any overtures of friendship. Jayla is obviously determined to alienate Cheryl—and everyone else in Sugarcreek. But Cheryl, spurred on by Mitzi’s encouraging letters, sets out to find the culprit behind the series of events that seem intended to terrorize Aunt Mitzi’s tenant. Who is targeting Jayla with these vicious pranks? Or is she herself causing the damage?
Meanwhile, when the Sugarcreek Nursing Home opens a brand new assisted living wing, the activities coordinator invites Naomi to give classes in Amish cooking. Will the accolades cause Naomi to be vain, and pull her away from serving her family on their own farm just when they need her most?
Homespun Suspicions – Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries – Book 29
Starting at $17.95 $7.99 -
Savannah Secrets – The Weight of Years – Book 6
Starting at $17.95 $9.99 -
Secrets From Grandma’s Attic Book 24: Coming Home
Starting at $17.95 $9.99 -
Secrets From Grandma’s Attic Book 5: Pearl of Great Price
Starting at $17.95 $9.99 -
When their church hosts a children’s choir from Aunt Mitzi’s mission in Papua New Guinea, Cheryl and Levi invite Jennifer Lewis, a young single woman and chaperone for the group, to stay in their dawdy haus. An hour before they need to leave to meet the group for their first rehearsal, they realize the woman has vanished. Has Jennifer left voluntarily—or is something more sinister afoot? As Cheryl sets out to learn what happened to their guest, a cryptic note left behind in the guest bedroom is her only clue.
Meanwhile, with toddler Rebecca growing more charming and delightful every day, Cheryl and Levi begin to wonder: is it time to open their hearts and home to another child?
Till We Meet Again – Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries – Book 30
Starting at $17.95 $7.99 -
Sweet Carolina Mysteries, formerly known as Miracles & Mysteries of Mercy Hospital. Same content, thrilling stories and enigmatic mysteries.
Embark on a thrilling journey with Evelyn Perry in Mercy Hospital! Missing husband, early baby arrival, embezzlement accusations—can they uncover the truth? Plus, delve into the secrets of Harriet Tubman’s Combahee River Raid and unearth forgotten heroism! Intrigue, courage, and hidden histories await in this must-read book!
Sweet Carolina Mysteries Book 6: Surrounded by Mercy
Starting at $17.95 $9.99 -
After losing a valuable watch on the newly-restored Mountain Crest Railroad’s inaugural trip, Sadie becomes determined to find out what happened to it. As her search progresses, nothing is quite as it seems. Who was the costumed man that sat next to her on the train ride? Could it be that a recently-deceased Silver Peak resident is still alive? Jump into another cozy mystery with more unexpected twists than the Mountain Crest Railroad!
Time Will Tell – Mysteries of Silver Peak Series – Book 6
Starting at $7.99 -
When Janet Shaw’s day at the Whistle Stop Café takes an unexpected turn with a break-in, she embarks on a journey to recover a stolen WWII photograph. Teaming up with her friend Debbie, they unravel a web of unsolved crimes and buried family secrets that threaten Dennison’s legacy. Can they unveil the truth hidden in the shadows?
Whistle Stop Café Mysteries Book 6: Fools Rush In
Starting at $17.95 $9.99 -
When Sadie plans on selling a few items from the Campfire Chapel’s attic in order to offset costs for her pen pal’s damaged church roof, Sadie discovers that her congregation isn’t as willing to allocate the funds as she thought. However, just as the debate heats up, the funds are stolen! Sadie’s quest to recover the money leads her to many interesting revelations, including a period during the Civil Rights movement when faith was more important than ever.
A Code of Honor – Mysteries of Silver Peak Series – Book 7
Starting at $7.99 -
When Sadie decides to display Edwin Marshall’s signed first-edition copy of A Christmas Carol for the annual Holly & Ivy Days Celebration in Silver Peak , it mysteriously vanishes without any clues regarding its whereabouts! Will the disappearance of the valuable book and a concerning revelation from Sadie’s grandson threaten to ruin the Christmas spirit in Silver Peak?
God Bless Us, Every One- Mysteries of Silver Peak Series – Book 15
Starting at $7.99 -
When Anne develops a roll of film found in her great-aunt Edie’s old camera, she is shocked to find a picture of her father’s cousin, Carl, at the bicentennial celebration for American independence in 1976. Carl was reportedly killed while fighting in the Vietnam War in 1970, so how is any of this possible? After going through more of Aunt Edie’s belongings, Anne decides to host an exhibition of her relative’s photography. Will Anne’s research put her closer to the truth behind Carl’s story, and what else will she learn about her family history?
Gone in a Flash – Secrets of the Blue Hill Library – Book 7
Starting at $9.99
Popular products
-
Free
Gift!Now the stories and passages in the Old and New Testaments are seamlessly sewn together in chronological order to form a unique presentation of the NIV Bible that reads like an epic novel.
FREE GIFT WITH PURCHASE! Receive a free downloadable e-booklet of Faith Builders – A Guideposts Classic by Norman Vincent Peale, an inspiring roadmap to deeper faith with powerful steps to overcome challenges, find inner peace, and trust in God. Delivered to your email after purchase.
The Daily Bible
$29.99 -
Experience a closer relationship with Jesus in just 5 minutes a day with Mornings with Jesus 2026. This popular devotional eases your worries and nourishes your soul with devotions especially written for a woman’s heart.
Free Gift – 12 Faith Step Cards
Mornings With Jesus 2026
Starting at$20.96$11.38 -
Join millions of Americans who start each day with this inspiring devotional. Our best-selling devotional helps you grow closer to God through true stories, Scripture, and original prayers. Formerly titled Daily Guideposts.
FREE SCRIPTURE BOOKMARK with any regular or large print purchase.
Walking in Grace 2026
Starting at$12.95$10.17 -
Are fear, perfectionism, or people-pleasing stealing your joy? The Lies That Bind reveals how to replace the lies we tell ourselves with God’s truth so we can live with confidence, joy, peace, and lasting self-confidence.
The Lies That Bind
$17.95 -
Curated from our best-selling women’s devotional, Mornings with Jesus, these devotions help you find joy in both ordinary and unexpected moments. Each story offers encouragement, Scripture, and quiet strength for whatever your day holds.
Rejoice in All Things
$16.95 -
Discover God’s mercies are new every morning. This beautifully illustrated journal features 40 prompts, 10 inspiring Bible verses, and space to reflect, pray, and grow in faith. A perfect companion for your daily walk with the Lord.
FREE GIFT WITH PURCHASE!
Receive a FREE downloadable e-booklet, 10 Ways to Invite God’s Calm into Your Life—a faith-filled guide offering Scripture-based encouragement and gentle reflections to help you find peace, deepen your trust in God, and quiet your heart amid daily life. Delivered to your email after purchase.
New Every Morning Journal
$19.99 -
Help your faith flourish with this beautifully designed softcover book, which offers 220 devotions filled with inspiration from the garden, Scripture, prayers, and action steps that will nurture your spirit and grow your faith.
FREE GIFT WITH PURCHASE!
Receive a free downloadable e-booklet, Grow in Faith, delivered to your email after purchase. This encouraging companion offers Scripture-based reflections and practical faith steps designed to help you nurture your spiritual growth and deepen your relationship with God.Inspiration from the Garden
$19.95 -
Unforgettable, never-before-published true stories of people rescued, protected, or guided by God’s messengers at just the right moment. These dramatic, first-person accounts will strengthen your faith like never before.
FREE GIFTS WITH PURCHASE!
Receive a free Tote and (4) Angel Note Cards with purchase.Angels in Our Lives Book 1: Saved by an Angel
Starting at $17.95 $15.95 -
Sarah returns home to open a gift and curiosities shop—only to uncover secrets hidden among the treasures. As mysteries unfold, her cozy store becomes a haven of hope, truth, and second chances in this heartwarming small-town story.
FREE GIFT WITH PURCHASE!
Get a Free “Heavenly Blessings” Tote Bag and Genuine Amethyst Bead Stretch Bracelet when you join the series.Gift Shop Mysteries Book 1: A Gift in Time
Starting at $17.95 $15.95
































