Free Standard Shipping $35+ w/ code FREESHIP35 | Need it for XMAS? Shipping & Gift Info
Home » Christian Fiction Books » Mystery Christian Fiction » Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Shopping Options

Category
Price

Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

Sit back and enjoy a vacation for your soul with Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries. This uplifting, fascinating, and inspiring series whisks you away to the scenic hillside of Ohio’s Amish country and draws you into the excitement as Cheryl and her Amish friend, Naomi, work together to solve highly intriguing mysteries. These well-written stories of the strong bond that develops between two women of vastly different backgrounds and traditions will tug at your heartstrings and provide hours of entertainment, intrigue, and wonder. In addition to Cheryl’s keen insight and excellent riddle solving ability, you’ll love experiencing Naomi’s proverbial Amish wisdom and exploring her down-to-earth faith.

  • 11% off Blessings in Disguise - Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Series - Book 1-0

    Sit back and enjoy a vacation for your soul with Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries. This uplifting, fascinating, and inspiring series whisks you away to the scenic hillside of Ohio’s Amish country and draws you into the excitement as Cheryl and her Amish friend, Naomi, work together to solve highly intriguing mysteries.

    Free Gifts with Purchase ($30 value)! A gold-tone filigree heart necklace and sturdy tote FREE with Book 1 purchase or series join.

    $17.95
  • 11% off Where Hope Dwells Book Cover

    The Amish of Sugarcreek are experiencing a baby boom and the community couldn’t be happier to welcome the newborns into the world! However, when a family reports that one of their newborn twins is missing, questions are raised. Who could have done such a thing, and are the children of Sugarcreek truly safe? Find out in this page-turning adventure that demonstrates the power of faith, and a little clever sleuthing, in the time of a crisis!

    $17.95
  • 11% off The Buggy Before the Horse Book Cover

    As Thanksgiving approaches, many businesses along Sugarcreek’s Main Street have reported incidents of theft! With the safety of her gift shop’s inventory at stake, Cheryl becomes motivated to get to the bottom of these crimes. Her investigation leads to many potential suspects, including an individual who has been secretly living out of Naomi and Seth Miller’s winter buggy! Will Cheryl find the culprit before the residents of Sugarcreek suffer more serious economic casualties? Read on in this tale of empathy and compassion in the cozy community of Sugarcreek!

    $17.95
  • 11% off A Season of Secrets Book Cover

    Cheryl’s assistant at the Swiss Miss Gift Shop, Lydia Troyer, has received a mysterious message from an unknown number claiming to have information regarding Lydia’s cousin, Mark Troyer. While many believed that Mark left Sugarcreek to pursue opportunities outside of the Amish community, Lydia has had her doubts. Will Cheryl and her friends in Sugarcreek be able to close the books on this case, or will the Troyer family have to accept the idea that they may never know what happened to Mark?

    $17.95
  • 11% off O Little Town of Sugarcreek Book Cover

    Cheryl’s Christmas is off to a rather profound start… Her ex-fiancé has returned into her life and attempts to propose again! But when his engagement ring, in addition to Cheryl’s aunt’s heirloom, is stolen, marriage is no longer the first thought on anyone’s mind. Additionally, the Millers’ daughter, Sarah, has returned to Sugarcreek… But will her return contribute to or destroy the family’s Christmas cheer? Find out in O Little Town of Sugarcreek, a cozy holiday story that will warm the cockles of any reader!

    $17.95
  • 11% off Off the Beaten Path Book Cover

    Cheryl and Levi are looking forward to hosting a “Live Like the Amish” special at the Miller family farm. However, when the guests and their bus mysteriously disappear en route to the event, it’s up to Cheryl and her friends from Sugarcreek to investigate and prevent further catastrophe!

    $17.95
  • 11% off Peace Like a River Book Cover

    Naomi and Seth Miller have had a lot of tension building up between them lately, and Cheryl wants to help bring them together for Valentine’s Day. Nothing is ever as simple as it seems, however, and as Cheryl receives help investigating their relationship from an unlikely source, she uncovers the events of one fateful summer day…  Could this be the force that has been driving Naomi and Seth farther apart each day?

    $17.95
  • 11% off Simply Vanished Book Cover

    The discovery of an old laundry chute in the Swiss Miss Gift Shop reignites the mystery of a woman who disappeared long ago in Sugarcreek! Is there a connection between the two? Meanwhile, Cheryl’s parents and her brother, Matt, are in town to visit, but will family tensions threaten to break their relationship with one another? Will a family’s love be enough to overcome the forces that threaten to drive them apart?

    $17.95
  • 11% off A Stitch in Time Book Cover

    When Naomi needs to see a sick relative, Cheryl is more than happy to drive her. Along the way, Cheryl buys a unique quilt from an estate sale. However, there appears to be a mystery behind this quilt, as various attempts are made to steal it from her! Cheryl’s investigation reveals that her recent purchase holds more value than the fabric that holds it together. With people’s reputations and well-beings on the line, Cheryl must decide whether or not revealing the past is worth hurting those in the present…

    $17.95
  • 11% off Mason Jar Mayhem Book Cover

    During an effort made by the community of Sugarcreek to help those affected by domestic violence, dozens of old coins are found and stored in Cheryl’s safe at the Swiss Miss Gift Shop. When the money is stolen, Cheryl embarks on an investigation that leads her back into the pages of history! Will she be able to recover the coins and uncover the thief, or is the mystery destined to remain unsolved forever? Find out in the tenth contribution to the Sugrcreek Amish Mysteries series, a wonderful tale of charity and modesty from the charmingly picturesque town of Sugarcreek!

    $17.95
  • 11% off When There's a Will Book Cover

    Following the death of Seth’s Uncle Silas, the Miller family is spending time mourning the loss of a loved one. Meanwhile, Levi is relieved to hear that he will inherit land from Silas, but will the arrival of a shady developer—coinciding with the disappearance of the deed to Silas’s land—threaten Levi’s ownership of the property? As always, Cheryl and her friends from Sugarcreek are on the case!

    $17.95
  • 11% off Shoo Fly Shoo Book Cover

    Albert Yoder has been arrested for illegally distributing and selling raw milk across county lines, and his wife has had to be rushed to the hospital to give birth! As a result, Cheryl and Naomi offer to assist Albert’s six young daughters with maintaining the farm— all while investigating a few suspect relationships between Albert’s dairy farm and multiple shady figures. Was Albert in over his head, and was he hiding something from his family? With the overwhelming wealth of suspect circumstances, will this mystery prove to be too much for even Cheryl and Naomi to solve?

    $17.95

Popular products

Community Newsletter

Get More Inspiration Delivered to Your Inbox

Donate to change a life together

Scroll to Top