30% OFF + FREE SHIPPING on $35+ | Code: LAST30 | Order by 12/8 for Christmas gifts

Filters

Category
  • Amish Fiction
  • Best Selling Fiction Books
  • Blackberry Valley Mysteries
  • Book Sets
  • Christian Fiction Books
  • Christian Fiction Romance
  • Cozy Mysteries
  • eBooks
  • Fiction eBooks
  • General Fiction Books
  • Holiday Fiction
  • Mysteries & Wonders of the Bible
  • Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm
  • Mysteries of Lancaster County
  • Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard
  • Mysteries of Silver Peak
  • Mystery Christian Fiction
  • New Release Christian Books
  • Patchwork Mysteries
  • Sale
  • Savannah Secrets
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic
  • Secrets of Mary's Bookshop
  • Secrets of the Blue Hill Library
  • Secrets of Wayfarers Inn
  • Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries
  • Tearoom Mysteries
  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries
Price

Mystery Christian Fiction

Category
  • Amish Fiction
  • Best Selling Fiction Books
  • Blackberry Valley Mysteries
  • Book Sets
  • Christian Fiction Books
  • Christian Fiction Romance
  • Cozy Mysteries
  • eBooks
  • Fiction eBooks
  • General Fiction Books
  • Holiday Fiction
  • Mysteries & Wonders of the Bible
  • Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm
  • Mysteries of Lancaster County
  • Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard
  • Mysteries of Silver Peak
  • Mystery Christian Fiction
  • New Release Christian Books
  • Patchwork Mysteries
  • Sale
  • Savannah Secrets
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic
  • Secrets of Mary's Bookshop
  • Secrets of the Blue Hill Library
  • Secrets of Wayfarers Inn
  • Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
  • Sweet Carolina Mysteries
  • Tearoom Mysteries
  • Whistle Stop Café Mysteries
Price
  • Things Unseen Book Cover

    When Sadie leaves her shop momentarily to help Luz at her coffee shop next door, Sadie’s deposit bag mysteriously disappears from the Antique Mine! What happened to the money, and could its disappearance have anything to do with the late stragglers in Sadie’s shop—as well as the unexplained sound she heard after hours? Simultaneously, Sadie discovers a false bottom in an antique armoire that she is restoring for a client! What secrets could the hidden compartment reveal?

  • Agree to Disagree Book Cover

    When a big-box discount store demonstrates an interest in building a location in Blue Hill, landowners compete fiercely with one another to potentially make the most profit. However, land surveys are becoming sabotaged and even the land itself is being damaged! Is this just a consequence of the competition between landowners, or does someone dislike the idea of a corporation coming into the cozy town of Blue Hill? Meanwhile, when Wendy leads a protest against the store coming into town, Anne refuses to support her because the store could possibly benefit poorer families in the area. Will Anne and Wendy be able to come to an understanding, or will their relationship be compromised in an irreparable way?

  • 11% off Earthly Treasures Book Cover

    After agreeing to participate in a treasure hunt in Sugarcreek, Cheryl begins to observe that there may be more to this event than what first meets the eye. As various aspects of the treasure hunt are sabotaged, including the disappearance of one the participants, Cheryl must investigate who is behind these sinister actions before more people are put in harm’s way!

    $17.95
  • 11% off In a Jam - Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries - Book 19

    Several people in Sugarcreek have ended up in the hospital after rat poison is discovered in the strawberry jam sold at the Swiss Miss Gift Shop! Locals are quick to point the finger at Naomi due to the fact that she is the only individual in the community who makes jam for the store, but Cheryl has her doubts. Will Cheryl be able to clear Naomi’s name and prove that her friend took no part in sabotaging the products? Find out in In a Jam, an adventure that shows that friendship is one of the strongest forces in the world.

    $17.95
  • Dangerous Beauty Book Cover

    When Sadie holds a sidewalk sale featuring many of the items she purchased at a recent auction, many customers mysteriously begin to fall ill! Could this be the fault of the food vendors, or is it something less obvious? Meanwhile, Sadie embarks on a quest to discover the identity of a beautiful woman depicted on one of the portraits she won at the auction. Her adventure leads her to a forgotten narrative in Silver Peak’s history about a murder and deceit; what is the secret behind the individual formerly known as the Black Widow? 

  • 11% off Simply Vanished Book Cover

    The discovery of an old laundry chute in the Swiss Miss Gift Shop reignites the mystery of a woman who disappeared long ago in Sugarcreek! Is there a connection between the two? Meanwhile, Cheryl’s parents and her brother, Matt, are in town to visit, but will family tensions threaten to break their relationship with one another? Will a family’s love be enough to overcome the forces that threaten to drive them apart?

    $17.95
  • 11% off A Slowly Developing Story- Front Cover

    Author: Nancy Mehl & Shean Layle

    $17.95
  • 11% off Secrets of Wayfarers Inn Book 26: The Bucket List-0

    Author: Janice Thompson

    $17.95
  • 11% off Where Hope Dwells Book Cover

    The Amish of Sugarcreek are experiencing a baby boom and the community couldn’t be happier to welcome the newborns into the world! However, when a family reports that one of their newborn twins is missing, questions are raised. Who could have done such a thing, and are the children of Sugarcreek truly safe? Find out in this page-turning adventure that demonstrates the power of faith, and a little clever sleuthing, in the time of a crisis!

    $17.95
  • 11% off Savannah Secrets - Buried Secrets - Book 21-0

    Author: Gabrielle Meyer

    $17.95
  • 11% off Submerged Surprises - Secrets of Wayfarers Inn - Book 16-0

    Author: Ocieanna Fleiss

    $17.95
  • 11% off Mysteries of Lancaster County Book 13: Beg, Borrow, or Steal-0

    Author: Anne Marie Rodgers

    $17.95
  • Secrets From Grandma's Attic Book 20: Veiled Intentions-0

    With the wedding weeks away, Amy’s life spins into chaos—her house sold, a mysterious saboteur cancels orders, and the cherished family veil disappears. Can she uncover the truth before saying “I do”?

  • 11% off Whistle Stop Café Mysteries Book 4: Till Then-0

    Janet and her friends embark on a thrilling journey to unravel the mysteries concealed within the time capsule. Join Janet to unveil forgotten history from a time capsule: photos, articles, mysteries, and more. Can you solve the puzzle?

    $17.95

Popular products

Community Newsletter

Get More Inspiration Delivered to Your Inbox

Donate to change a life together

Scroll to Top